Does the PAR Standard Agreement Require the Buyer, Rejected by a Lender or Insurer, to Make Additional Applications?

James L. Goldsmith, Esquire; Mette, Evans & Woodside • December 16, 2022

It happens. The buyer makes a good faith mortgage application and does everything requested of her, and yet, her application is denied. If the date for securing a mortgage commitment has not passed does the buyer have an obligation to make another mortgage application? 


That question was answered by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in a 1985 case, Ormond Realty v. Ninnis. The facts of that case date to August 1979 when the buyers made an offer, on a PAR Standard Agreement, that was contingent on mortgage financing. The agreement stated “buyers shall make a completed application to a responsible mortgage lending institution for the mortgage loan…within ten days from the seller’s approval hereof.” Sound familiar? It is not too much different from what we presently find in the mortgage contingency clause.


The court found that the buyers made a good faith effort to obtain the mortgage, but were unable to do so by the commitment date of October 20. A few weeks later, the buyers wrote to the broker holding the deposit funds stating that their failure to secure the mortgage by the commitment date meant that the agreement was null and void and so they were entitled to a return of their deposit (does that sound like a notice of termination?).


The Superior Court held that the failure to obtain the commitment rendered the agreement null and void and the buyers were entitled to their deposit money. Indeed, there are differences between that Standard Agreement and the present version. That agreement provided that if the loan cannot be obtained, the agreement was null and void. That language is not found in the present version though it is clear that the sale is “contingent upon Buyer obtaining mortgage financing…” So what happens when a buyer cannot obtain mortgage financing? Is the buyer obligated to make an application to a different lending institution? I hear some you answering “yes” and others “no.”


The difficulty comes from language in the present Standard Agreement that provides that “Buyer must continue to make a good faith effort to obtain mortgage financing” if the commitment date has arrived and the seller has not terminated. Yes, buyer must continue to make a good faith effort but does that include making a mortgage application to yet another lender? I argue “no” given the plain language of the agreement that provides that the buyer is to make “a mortgage application.” That is the language found in Ormond and it would seem that the court recognized that the plain meaning of “a” to mean “one.” 


If a buyer does not obtain a mortgage commitment by the commitment date, the buyer’s good faith effort is to do what is reasonably necessary follow up on the original application to hopefully make that loan available, assuming it is possible to do so. If additional information is required by the lender, it must be provided. However, when the buyer hits the end of the road, the buyer is not obligated to make an additional mortgage application to some other mortgage lender of buyer’s choosing or one selected by the seller or a broker or anyone else.


A similar issue has to do with the buyer’s choice of insurer. Assume that the buyer makes a mortgage application and is granted a commitment. The commitment will require that the buyer to obtain insurance by the date of closing for the protection of the lender and buyer. What happens when the buyer’s lender observes knob and tube wiring and requires that it be removed? This matter too is addressed in our Standard Agreement where it provides that if a “casualty insurer providing insurance required by the mortgage lender(s) requires repairs to the property…” the buyer may seek the repairs to be performed by the seller, and if the seller refuses to do so, buyer may terminate. What if the seller says that she will not repair but will find an insurer willing to insure the property? Is the buyer required to accept that insurer and proceed with purchase? Borrowing from Ormond it would appear that the plain language of the agreement does not require the buyer to seek a different type of policy or a policy issued by an insurer not selected by the buyer. Had that been intended, it would be included in the agreement in plain and clear language. 


This is an area of great confusion. Be on the know and take advantage of the Hotline when issues arise. And, when a dispute arises having to do with the issues addressed here, or any other issue for that matter, do not hesitate for one moment to suggest that your client engage counsel. Doing so will assure that you don’t become my client!!!


Copyright © James L. Goldsmith, Esquire 2022

All Rights Reserved.


 Mr. Goldsmith is an attorney with Mette, Evans & Woodside. He serves as outside legal counsel to numerous Realtor Associations and was a staple on the PAR Legal Hotline for many years.  A substantial portion of his practice is dedicated to providing advice and counsel to real estate licensees. He defends real estate salespersons and brokers in civil lawsuits and licensing claims across the Commonwealth. He represent Realtors® in disciplinary cases conducted before the Real Estate Commission. Jim was one of the voices of the PAR Legal Hotline for the first 27 years following its inception in 1992.



By Melissa Boots, Realty ONE Unlimited April 25, 2025
Chickens are becoming a hot topic…whether it’s the increase in egg prices, or the continuing interest in homesteading, more clients are expressing interest in raising chickens. Spring is approaching fast and adorable fuzzy, chicks will be looking for homes. Even in Lancaster County, it’s not as easy as throwing a coop in the backyard and joyfully collecting eggs.
By Host Mike Berk, LCAR Executive Director April 17, 2025
Featuring Host Mike Berk & Guest Chandra Mast, Red Rose Appraisals Welcome to the fourth episode of The LCAR Corner, the first-ever podcast from the Lancaster County Association of Realtors®. In this episode, LCAR's Executive Director, Mike Berk, chats with prompt specialist Chandra Mast about the cutting-edge trends shaping Artificial Intelligence as we know it. Together, they dive into how AI is transforming the real estate industry—from smarter listings to predictive analytics—and what it means for agents, buyers, and the future of the market. LCAR Members can register for Chandra's upcoming CE course on May 7th , "Fundamentals of Artificial Intelligence for Real Estate Professionals", on their LCAR Portal . Non-LCAR members can register for the course through the LCAR website . Stay tuned every month for more engaging episodes and expert advice from the world of real estate and beyond, right here on The LCAR Corner! Click Here For More Listening & Download Options
By Lisa Naples, Berkshire Hathaway HomeSale Homeservice Realty April 10, 2025
As a member of the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors (PAR) , you have access to a wide range of resources to support your real estate career. Here’s what’s included with your membership: Legal Support & Resources • Legal Hotline: Have a legal or regulatory question? PAR’s Legal Hotline provides information to support your clients. Submit a form online to verify your membership or call 800-555-3390 to receive the hotline number. Access the Legal Hotline here: https://www.parealtors.org/legal-hotline/ • Legal Help Articles: PAR offers an extensive library of Legal Help Articles for members. Browse the articles here (member login required): https://www.parealtors.org/legal-help-articles/ Market Data & Industry Reports • Pennsylvania Housing Market Report: In addition to LCAR's market reports, this monthly report provides insights into housing trends across the state. (Temporarily suspended as discrepancies in reporting are being corrected.) View the latest reports here: https://www.parealtors.org/housing-report/ Governance & Industry Involvement • Committees, Councils & Feedback Panels: Get involved with PAR leadership and decision-making by joining a committee or council. Apply for an appointment here: https://www.parealtors.org/governance/ Education & Professional Development • Webinars & Events: Stay informed with industry courses, webinars, and events designed to help you grow professionally. Find upcoming events here: https://www.parealtors.org/events/ • Triple Play Convention & Trade Expo: A joint convention for Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York Realtors, held annually in Atlantic City, NJ. The 2025 event takes place December 8-11. Advocacy & Political Action • RPAC (Realtors Political Action Committee): RPAC helps influence government decisions that impact the real estate industry, homeowners, and commercial businesses. Learn more about RPAC and advocacy efforts here: https://www.parealtors.org/advocacy/ Standard Forms & Transaction Tools • Standard Forms: PAR provides up-to-date standard forms used daily by real estate professionals. Members receive free access to fillable, electronic forms through Lone Wolf Transactions (zipForm edition). Access forms here: https://www.parealtors.org/resources/electronic-forms/ News & Industry Updates • JustListed Blog: Stay updated with the latest real estate news and trends. Subscribe to JustListed here: https://www.parealtors.org/blog/ Exclusive Discounts & Savings • Member Discounts on Products & Services : Take advantage of preferred partner savings on business and personal products. Explore membership savings here (login required): https://www.parealtors.org/membership-savings/ Your PAR membership is packed with valuable tools and resources to help you stay informed, supported, and successful. Take advantage of everything included and make the most of your membership! -Copyright © It's Included! - Your PAR Membership Benefits, Lisa Naples, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. 2025. All Rights Reserved. Facts, opinions and information expressed in the Blog represent the work of the author and are believed to be accurate, but are not guaranteed. The Lancaster County Association of Realtors is not liable for any potential errors, omissions or outdated information. If errors are noted within a post, please notify the Association. Posts represent the author's opinion and are not necessarily the opinion of the Association.
By Host Mike Berk, LCAR Executive Director March 27, 2025
In this episode, LCAR's Executive Director, Mike Berk, sits down with Lititz-based family therapist Stacey Kreitz to discuss mental health, work/life balance, and overall wellness. Stacey shares practical tips for managing stress, preventing burnout, setting boundaries, and creating a work-life balance for those managing a busy lifestyle. Whether you're a Realtor®, business owner, or simply looking to find balance in your day-to-day, this episode is full of helpful tips to improve your well-being and maintain a healthier work-life balance.
By Victoria Medvedeva, Keller Williams Elite March 20, 2025
Ready to dig? Well hold your shovels! In this quick 2 minute read, LCAR's Victoria Medvedeva goes over the quick Do's and Don'ts when it comes to digging on your property. Don't dig yourself into a hole...discover what you need to do when it comes to digging on home properties.
By Dan Ranck, Homesale Mortgage March 7, 2025
In this 2-minute video, Mortgage Loan Officer Dan Ranck discusses how recent changes to buyer agency commissions are impacting the homebuying process, especially for first-time buyers. He highlights the importance of communication between agents and lenders to ensure buyers can navigate these new challenges and secure their dream home.
By Host Mike Berk, LCAR Executive Director February 27, 2025
Welcome to the second episode of The LCAR Corner, the first-ever podcast from the Lancaster County Association of Realtors®. In this episode, LCAR's Executive Director, and your host, Mike Berk meets with Shelby Nauman, Chief Executive Officer at Tenfold, to discuss and learn more about the many programs Tenfold has to offer. From transitional living to first-time homebuyer programs, tune in to learn about the unique connection between LCAR and Tenfold, which has flourished since LCAR members began fundraising efforts back in 1989.
By Lisa Naples, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty February 20, 2025
As real estate professionals, we know the value of connections, resources, and staying informed. Your Lancaster County Association of Realtors (LCAR) membership comes packed with benefits designed to help you grow your business, network with colleagues, and access valuable industry resources. But are you taking full advantage of what’s included?
computer screen of audio
By Host Mike Berk, LCAR Executive Director February 7, 2025
In this episode, meet your host, LCAR Executive Director Mike Berk, as he sits down with Tim Keller, LCAR Treasurer and Auctioneer at H.K. Keller, to break down the basics of real estate auctions.
By Nestfully January 23, 2025
Collaborate, communicate, and cultivate client relationships with the cutting-edge app that’s built to keep you at the heart of your clients’ home journeys.
More Posts